This is Scale & Strategy, the heart rate monitor of business newsletters (we help you check the market’s pulse).
Here’s what we got for you today:
Why Now Is the Right Time to Reinvent Your Hiring Process
Hiring might be slowing down, speeding up, or pausing depending on the week’s economic mood swing. Either way, it’s still the perfect moment to rethink how you hire. When you’re not scrambling to fill seats, you finally have the breathing room to step back and rebuild the process intentionally, from job description to offer.
And as bigger companies freeze hiring or downsize, early-stage teams with runway have a window to stand out. If the market is noisy, clarity becomes the differentiator. A tighter, more thoughtful hiring process doesn’t just make you look more credible to candidates — it helps you actually pick the right people.
The irony: the tech world prides itself on innovation, but hiring workflows are usually stuck in 2012. As Amber Madison, co-founder of Peoplism, puts it: companies will reinvent entire industries but copy-paste their hiring practices from whatever they saw last on LinkedIn.
The result? The same broken loops everyone complains about. Five-hour interview marathons. Vague feedback. “We’ll know it when we see it” selection criteria. Ghosting candidates who took time to meet you. It’s sloppy, it’s avoidable, and it’s costing companies top talent.
Peoplism’s point isn’t to add more steps. It’s the opposite: get clear, get intentional, and cut the nonsense. Their approach includes things most companies wouldn’t dare: screening with a short survey instead of resumes, sending interview questions upfront, and ditching hiring committees that drag decisions out.
For business operators scaling from $1M to $10M, leverage is everything. AI can automate, but it can’t anticipate, contextualize, or build trust.
The smartest operators already know: the future isn’t AI-only. It’s AI paired with capable, strategic human support.
That’s the idea behind our latest guide: The 5 Traits AI Can’t Replace & Why They Matter More Than Ever. A fast, actionable read for business operators who want to scale with clarity — not just speed.
And when you're ready to put those traits into action?
BELAY matches you with U.S.-based Executive Assistants who bring judgment, initiative, and relational intelligence to your business — not just task management.
Step 1: Treat the Job Description Like It Actually Matters
Job descriptions get the least attention and cause the most downstream pain. Most companies reuse old descriptions or copy competitors, which is a guaranteed way to create confusion later.
A good JD forces you to clarify what success actually looks like. Once that’s aligned, the rest of the hiring process becomes dramatically easier. Interview questions, evaluation rubrics, even who should be on the loop becomes obvious instead of improvisational.
Startups don’t have the luxury of coasting on brand recognition. A thoughtful JD is often the first (and only) signal candidates use to decide whether to engage.
Peoplism’s job descriptions follow four pillars:
Skills we will evaluate you on.
The impact this role has.
What success looks like in the first 6+ months.
What we value as a company.
Their team starts by listing 10–12 traits that would make someone incredible at the role, then aggressively narrows to five non-negotiables. More than that just shrinks the applicant pool unnecessarily.
And those hiring competencies should later map to performance reviews. If your hiring criteria and your performance criteria don’t match, your entire talent system is misaligned.
For their senior consultant roles, Peoplism hires against these five traits:
Action-oriented analytical skills
High-touch consulting capability
Proactive, organized, deadline-driven
Strong emotional intelligence
Deep understanding of systems of inequality
And yes, they always publish salary ranges. It’s transparent, it builds trust, and it avoids messy conversations later.
Step 2: Stop Using Resumes as the First Filter
Resumes are easy to submit, fast to inflate, and terrible predictors of actual ability. They also introduce bias instantly — pedigree, past company logos, or education become shortcuts that rarely correlate with performance.
Peoplism replaces the resume dump with a three-question Google Form. That’s it. Resumes are optional. No cover letters.
Their three questions (200–300 words each) focus entirely on competencies tied to the role. They review answers blindly — no names, no backgrounds, no identifying info — and score them before looking at resumes.
This produces a much clearer snapshot of who’s genuinely qualified and motivated, without drowning in 300 irrelevant applications.
And importantly: candidates who don’t move forward get a response. No ghosting.
Step 3: Write Better Interview Questions — Then Share Them in Advance
Most early-stage teams don’t have structured interview rubrics, so questions get made up on the spot. Candidates notice. It makes the company look disorganized, and it doesn’t give you signal.
Peoplism builds a clear set of questions directly tied to the competencies defined in the JD — and then sends most of those questions to candidates ahead of time.
It sounds radical. It isn’t.
On-the-spot interviewing disproportionately rewards people who have insider connections, elite-school grooming, or friends already at the company feeding them prep. That has nothing to do with whether they can do the job.
If you want to see someone’s true capability, give them the context to show it.
A thorough prep guide, clear expectations, and transparency around what you’re evaluating levels the playing field and improves the quality of the conversation.
The Bottom Line
Most companies aren’t suffering from a lack of applicants. They’re suffering from chaotic processes, vague criteria, and an outdated mindset about what makes someone great at their job.
Peoplism’s system forces clarity, builds trust with candidates, and produces better hires with less wasted time. If you’re going to reinvent anything this year, start with the part of your company that determines who gets to build it with you.
